|
By:
Douglas Carlton Abrams
Summary:
It takes a lot more than
testosterone to make a
father out of a man.
Research shows that hormonal
changes in both sexes help
shape men into devoted dads.
If testosterone is the
defining hormone of
masculinity, it's time to
redefine manhood.
One
of my first memories
growing up was wishing
that my father would be
home more" recalls
Andrew Hudnut M.D, a
family doctor in
Sacramento, California.
"I was 8, and we had
just returned from a canoe
trip. I remember thinking,
'I don't want a bigger
house or more money. I
just want my dad
around.'"
When
his wife gave birth,
Hudnut arranged his
practice so he could be
home to take care of his
son, Seamus, two days a
week; he sees patients on
the other three workdays.
"It was a very
natural transition,"
he reports. "I'm
grateful to have the
opportunity my father
never had."
Part
of a new generation of men
who are redefining
fatherhood and
masculinity, Hudnut, who
is 33, is unwilling to
accept the role of
absentee provider that his
father's generation
assumed. With mothers
often being the
breadwinners of the
family, many young fathers
are deciding that a man's
place can also be in the
home—part-time or even
full-time.
According
to census figures, one in
four dads takes care of
his preschooler during the
time the mother is
working. The number of
children who are raised by
a primary-care father is
now more than 2 million
and counting. By all
measures, fathers, even
those who work full-time,
are more involved in their
children's lives than ever
before. According to the
Families and Work
Institute in New York
City, fathers now provide
three-fourths of the child
care mothers do, up from
one-half 30 years ago.
Is
Father Nurture Natural?
Many
men and women wonder if
all of this father care is
really natural. According
to popular perceptions,
men are supposedly driven
by their hormones
(primarily testosterone)
to compete for status, to
seek out sex and even to
be violent—conditions
hardly conducive to
raising kids. A recent
article in Reader's
Digest, "Why Men
Act As They Do," is
subtitled "It's the
Testosterone,
Stupid." Calling the
hormone "a metaphor
for masculinity," the
article concludes,
"...testosterone
correlates with risk:
physical, criminal, and
personal." Don't
men's testosterone-induced
chest-beating and
risk-taking limit their
ability to cradle and
comfort their children?
Two
Canadian studies suggest
that there is much more to
masculinity than
testosterone. While
testosterone is certainly
important in driving men
to conceive a child, it
takes an array of other
hormones to turn men into
fathers. And among the
best fathers, it turns
out, testosterone levels
actually drop
significantly after the
birth of a child. If
manhood includes
fatherhood, which it does
for a majority of men,
then testosterone is
hardly the ultimate
measure of masculinity.
In
fact, the second of the
two studies, which was
recently published in the Mayo
Clinic Proceedings,
suggests that fathers have
higher levels of estrogen
the well-known female sex
hormone—than other men.
The research shows that
men go through significant
hormonal changes alongside
their pregnant partners
changes most likely
initiated by their
partner's pregnancy and
ones that even cause some
men to experience
pregnancy-like symptoms
such as nausea and weight
gain. It seems
increasingly clear that
just as nature prepares
women to be committed
moms, it prepares men to
be devoted dads.
"I
have always suspected that
fatherhood has biological
effects in some, perhaps
all, men," says
biologist Sue Carter,
distinguished professor at
the University of
Maryland. "Now here
is the first hard evidence
that men are biologically
prepared for
fatherhood."
The
studies have the potential
to profoundly change our
understanding of families,
of fatherhood and of
masculinity itself. Being
a devoted parent is not
only important but also
natural for men. Indeed,
there is evidence that men
are biologically involved
in their children's lives
from the beginning.
Is
Biology Destiny for Dads?
It's
well known that hormonal
changes caused by
pregnancy encourage a
mother to love and nurture
her child. But it has long
been assumed that a
father's attachment to his
child is the result of a
more uncertain process, a
purely optional emotional
bonding that develops over
time, often years. Male
animals in some species
undergo hormonal changes
that prime them for
parenting. But do human
dads? The two studies,
conducted at Memorial
University and Queens
University in Canada,
suggest that human dads
do.
In
the original study,
published in Evolution
and Human Behavior,
psychologist Anne Storey,
and her colleagues took
blood samples from 34
couples at different times
during pregnancy and
shortly after birth. The
researchers chose to
monitor three specific
hormones because of their
links to nurturing
behavior in human mothers
and in animal fathers.
The
first hormone, prolactin,
gets its name from the
role it plays in promoting
lactation in women, but it
also instigates parental
behavior in a number of
birds and mammals. Male
doves who are given
prolactin start brooding
and feeding their young,
Storey found that in human
fathers, prolactin levels
rise by approximately 20
percent during the three
weeks before their
partners give birth.
The
second hormone, cortisol,
is well known as a stress
hormone, but it is also a
good indicator of a
mother's attachment to her
baby. New mothers who have
high cortisol levels can
detect their own infant by
odor more easily than
mothers with lower
cortisol levels. The
mothers also respond more
sympathetically to their
baby's cries and describe
their relationship with
their baby in more
positive terms. Storey and
her colleagues found that
for expectant fathers,
cortisol was twice as high
in the three weeks before
birth than earlier in the
pregnancy.
Biologist
Katherine Wynne-Edwards,
who conducted the research
with Storey, explains that
while cortisol is seen as
the "fight or
flight" hormone, it
might more accurately be
described as the
"heads-up-eyes-forward-something-really-important-is-happening"
hormone. It may help
prepare parents for
approaching birth.
Cortisol levels normally
increase in women as
pregnancy advances;
indeed, a cumulative rise
in stress-hormone levels
sets off labor and
delivery.
The
third hormone,
testosterone, is abundant
in male animals during
mating but decreases
during nurturing. If bird
fathers are given
testosterone, they spend
more time defending their
territory and mating than
taking care of existing
offspring. Research has
shown that human males
experience a surge in
testosterone when they win
sporting events and other
competitions.
In
Storey's study,
testosterone levels
plunged 33 percent in
fathers during the first
three weeks after birth.
Levels then returned to
normal by the time the
babies were four to seven
weeks old. However brief
the dip in testosterone,
it may have effects that
endure for the life of the
child. According to
University of California
at Riverside psychologist
Ross Parke, it may
"let the nurturing
side of men come to center
stage." The dip may
set in motion the
more-cooperative,
less-competitive
enterprise of parenting.
By encouraging fathers to
interact with their kids,
this brief hormonal change
might actually induce the
bonding process.
Estrogen
and the Daddy Brain
Wynne-Edwards
and graduate student
Sandra Berg designed
another study to test
Storey and Wynne-Edwards'
earlier findings. They
measured the hormone
levels of the fathers over
a longer period of time
and incorporated into the
study a control group of
men who had never had
children. The control
group was matched by age,
season and time of day
tested—all of which can
affect hormone levels.
Finally, by using saliva
samples instead of blood
draws, they were able to
test the fathers and the
men in the control group
much more frequently.
In
addition to confirming the
earlier findings for
testosterone reduction and
cortisol change, the
researchers also found
that the fathers had
elevated levels of
estrogen. The increase
started 30 days before
birth and continued during
all 12 weeks of testing
after birth. Although
estrogen is best known as
a female sex hormone, it
exists in small quantities
in men, too. Animal
studies show that estrogen
can induce nurturing
behavior in males.
Acting
in the brain as well as in
other parts of the body,
estrogen in men, and
testosterone in women,
makes humans extremely
versatile behaviorally.
"We spend an awful
lot of time looking for
differences between the
sexes and trumpeting them
when we find them,"
observes Wynne-Edwards,
"but our brains are
remarkably similar, built
from the same DNA."
In
fact, going into the
study, Wynne-Edwards
predicted that the
"daddy brain"
would use the same nerve
circuits, triggered by
many of the same hormones,
as the "mommy
brain." "If
Mother Nature wanted to
turn on parental behavior
in a male," she
reasoned, "the
easiest thing would be to
turn on pathways already
there for maternal
behavior."
The
studies also found that a
father's hormonal changes
closely paralleled those
of his pregnant partner.
The
Intimacy Effect
The
researchers believe that
intimate contact and
communication between
partners may induce the
hormonal changes that
encourage a father to
nurture his children.
Storey explains, "My
best guess is that women's
hormone levels are timed
to the birth—and men's
hormone levels are tied to
their partners."
Exactly
how this occurs is
unknown. There may be
actual physiological
signals exchanged between
partners in close contact,
such as the transmission
of pheromones. Similar to
odors, pheromones are
volatile chemical
substances that animals
constantly give off
through their skin or
sweat but that are
undetectable. Pheromones
can stimulate specific
reactions—especially
mating—in other animals.
Think of a female dog in
heat attracting all those
barking mate dogs in the
neighborhood.
Classic
studies show that
menstruation is
communicated, and
synchronized, through
pheromones among dorm
mates in college. If women
in dorms respond to one
another's pheromones, then
a man and a woman who
share intimate space could
certainly communicate
chemical messages. These
pheromones could
biologically cue a man
that his partner is
pregnant and kick off the
hormonal changes that
prompt him to be a dad in
deed as well as in seed.
Pregnancy certainly could,
in fact, be signaled.
The
level of intimacy within a
couple seems to be a
factor in how a mother's
body chemically signals
approaching birth to a
father. All of the men
tested were living with
their pregnant partners.
Emotional closeness may
also generate hormonal
changes, although this
possibility was not
examined in detail. Still,
couples reported feeling
closer to their partner if
they were taking about the
baby and sharing details
about the pregnancy.
Whether
this is the cause or the
result of hormonal changes
remains unknown for now.
But the intimacy effect
and the subsequent
hormonal shifts may also
be the reason many men
experience pregnancylike
symptoms.
Honey,
We're Pregnant
When
he is not taking care of
Seamus, Hudnut treats both
men and women in his
practice. He recalls
several patients who came
to him complaining of such
typical pregnancy symptoms
as weight gain and
nausea—all of whom were
men. He remembers one
second-time father who
knew that his wife was
pregnant even before she
told him. He started
having morning sickness,
just as he had during her
first pregnancy.
Pregnancy
symptoms in men are
actually more common than
most people believe. Two
studies found that
approximately 90 percent
of men experience at least
one pregnancy-related
symptom, sometimes severe
enough to prompt an
expectant father to seek
medical help.
According
to a study reported in Annals
of Internal Medicine,
more than 20 percent of
men with pregnant wives
sought care for symptoms
related to pregnancy
"that could not
otherwise be objectively
explained."
Unfortunately, like
pregnancy symptoms in
women, there is little
that can be done to make
the symptoms go
away—except wait.
Pregnancy
symptoms in men, however
well documented, are
generally dismissed as
being all in the
father-to-be's head. Now
it seems they may also be
in his hormones. Storey
and her colleagues found
that the men who
experienced more pregnancy
symptoms actually had
higher levels of prolactin.
They also had a greater
reduction in testosterone
after exposure to sounds
of crying and other
"infant cues"
that simulated the
experience of being with
an actual baby.
For
men who feel nauseated or
gain weight, no one yet
knows for sure whether the
changes in hormones are to
blame. Surging hormones,
however, have long been
blamed for women's morning
sickness and other
pregnancy side effects.
The fact that men also
experience hormone changes
suggests it is more than
empathy that causes many
of them to feel their
partner's pain.
Changed
by a Child
While
it now seems a father may
accompany his wife on her
hormonal roller coaster
during pregnancy,
interacting with the baby
may keep his hormones
spinning even after the
birth.
It's
no secret that hormone
levels can change in
response to behavior. Sex,
sports and work success
can all send testosterone
production spiraling
upward. Might not
nurturing a child—or
conversely, the sight,
sound and smell of a
newborn—also change
fathers' levels of
testosterone?
In
the original study, the
researchers asked couples
to hold dolls that had
been wrapped in receiving
blankets worn by a newborn
within the preceding 24
hours. (After their wives
gave birth, fathers held
their actual baby.) They
listened to a six-minute
tape of a real newborn
crying and then watched a
video of a baby struggling
to breast-feed. The
investigators took blood
from the men and women
before the test and 30
minutes later.
What
they found is startling:
Men who expressed the
greatest desire to comfort
the crying baby had the
highest prolactin levels
and the greatest reduction
in testosterone. And
testosterone levels
plummeted in those men who
held the doll for the full
half-hour.
Even
though scientists have
long observed changes in
animal and human behavior
as a result of shifting
hormone levels, they do
not yet understand exactly
how hormones accomplish
such change. The
hormone-behavior link
remains one of the great
mysteries of the brain.
Perhaps hormones stimulate
more neuron connections in
the part of the brain
responsible for nurturing.
Or perhaps hormones
encourage neurons in
nurturing pathways to fire
more quickly.
Wynne-Edwards
thinks hormones might turn
a two-lane pathway in the
father's brain into a
four-lane superhighway. A
neural road expansion
might make fathers better
able to recognize the
smell or sound of their
baby. It might even act on
smell receptors in the
nose to mitigate the smell
of a baby's dirty diaper.
Countless are the ways in
which hormones could
influence a father's brain
to be more responsive to
his baby.
Home
on the Range
Although
testosterone may be the
"primary" male
sex hormone, research
makes it clear that other
hormones are also
significant, especially
during the transition into
fatherhood Wynne-Edwards
believes the research is
"a validation of the
experiences that men know
they have had. It also
goes a long way to bumping
testosterone off its
pedestal as the only
hormone that is important
to men."
Parke
believes that the research
suggests something even
more radical: "Men
are much more androgynous
than we think." We
have the capability to be
aggressive and nurturing.
The traditional view of
men as predominantly
aggressive really sells
men short and denies their
capability to experience
the range of human
emotions.
The
research suggests that a
man's hormones may play an
important role in helping
him experience this full
range of emotions
especially in becoming a
loving and devoted dad. In
fact, it offers the first
evidence that to nurture
is part of man's nature.
Article courtesy:
www.psychologytoday.com
|